Welcome to Theo's Ice Cream
At Theo's Ice Cream, located in Peoria, IL, we celebrate the joy of indulgence with a vast selection of ice creams, frozen yogurts, and delightful sundaes. Our story begins with a commitment to high-quality ingredients, ensuring every scoop bursts with flavor, from timeless classics to innovative creations. Customers rave about unique offerings like the banana cream pie Iceberg and a variety of toppings that elevate every treat. While the cozy location may have its quirks, the friendly staff and vibrant atmosphere make it a cherished local favorite. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick cone or an entire sundae experience, Theo's is the go-to destination for sweet satisfaction.
-
3633 N Gale Ave, Peoria, IL 61604 Hotline: (309) 688-5854
If you’re on the hunt for a delectable frozen treat in Peoria, look no further than Theo's Ice Cream. Nestled at 3633 N Gale Ave, Peoria, IL 61604, this charming ice cream spot is more than just a destination for a scoop — it's a community hub where flavors come to life and memories are made.
The allure of Theo's lies not only in its exceptional ice cream, but also in the vibrancy of its offerings. From classic flavors to unique creations, there’s something for every palate. Ever wanted to try a scrumptious large sundae with a wealth of toppings ranging from chocolate syrup to peach? Here, the choices are endless, with large sundaes priced at an easy-going $3.30 and super sundaes at just $3.90. Do you prefer a cone? A medium cone starts at $2.20 and goes up to $2.75 for a large. There's even a baby cone for those who want a taste without the commitment, priced at just $1.10.
But it's not just ice cream that steals the show. Theo's boasts a diverse menu that includes frozen yogurt options available in a variety of cone sizes and quart servings. Their Waffle Cone for $3.30 or a pint of frozen yogurt for $4.65 might just tempt you away from your usual scoop of ice cream.
Customer reviews echo the joy of dining at Theo's. One enthusiastic visitor remarked, "Theo's is The-o place to be for ice cream," highlighting its long-standing reputation in the area. While the location can pose parking challenges, it’s a minor trade-off for the rewarding experience that awaits inside. Diners have delighted in unique flavors like espresso and coffee, with patrons like Joshua D. and Luke W. noting the ample selection and eager-to-please staff. The real fruit in their ice cream mixes, as noted by Luke, elevates the experience, allowing you to enjoy fresh, vibrant flavors in every bite.
Moreover, Theo's is more than just a sweet treat destination; it offers a variety of savory bites. Customers are raving about their food offerings too, from the all-time favorite chili dogs to BBQ sandwiches. Amy S. gushed about the delightful banana cream pie Iceberg as a must-try for dessert lovers.
With a friendly atmosphere, incredible prices, and seasonal variety, Theo's Ice Cream is a must-visit this summer. Remember to bring some cash, as this beloved local treasure offers a cash-only system to keep it quaint and personal. So gather your friends and family, indulge your cravings, and head over to Theo's for an unforgettable treat that continues to charm the people of Peoria!
Review Visit: June 17th, 2015 Theo's is The-o place to be for ice cream. Peoria seems to have a lot of ice cream places and Theo's was next on my list to visit. So, I gathered my good travel buddy Matt and my girlfriend at the time to drive there and check it out. I have actually tried to visit Theo's a few times prior to this but the location is just odd. It's kind of on the corner of a busy main street and a busy side street. Due to that, it's a pretty hopping place to go. On top of that, the parking arrangement is also strange. There is maybe room for a few cars in front of the building and a few spots on the side of the building but beyond that, you are relegated to using the curbs along the road. On our way there, we devised a Plan B as we have failed to try and get Theo's before. Luckily, we beat the crowd and were able to find a place to park. Memory is a bit foggy on this part but I believe Theo's is/was cash only. Don't quote me on that but do make sure you have some money on you as a precaution. I don't exactly remember what I ordered. I think it was an espresso-flavored ice cream while my girlfriend ordered a coffee-flavored one. We, of course, sampled what the other got. I have to be honest and say that while mine was great, her choice in flavors was 10x better. We actually came back by ourselves on another day and I got what she got and was happy. Matt ordered something unique off the menu. I don't remember what it was but he said it was delicious. I think it was a low-calorie ice cream treat. Since we ordered simple ice creams, we didn't have to wait too long for the cashier to yell out our order to pick them up. If you've never been to a proper ice cream shack, do know that if you order a lot of food it can take awhile to get it as they usually cook the food fresh and to-order. Theo's does offer a wide variety of options between ice cream and food. I have yet to try their non-ice cream offerings but I would imagine they are pretty good. At least the photos I've seen on Google/Yelp makes their food look good. If I do get to try their food, I will add my thoughts of it to this post.
Annoying cash only and tiny parking lot but massive menu! Wow! So much to try, plenty of flavors, eager to please staff and putting some real fruit in my Iceberg (Blizzard). However I picked the blueberry cheesecake but it was definitely not cheesecake at all, nothing resembling that cheesecake twang or mouthfeel or any taste resemblance whatsoever. My other two buddies were happy with their purchases, cookie dough always a safe bet! Could see this place being a ripe hotspot all summer for decent prices and friendly staff - if only a way to avoid needing cash and getting into a rewards program to up the ice cream game.
So good. I've been coming here since last month. I just moved to the area but this place is my favorite.
Great place for ice cream and more. I love the chili dogs! They are the best. BBQ sandwich is good too.
Amazing ice cream treats, my favorite is the banana cream pie Iceberg!! They are a great little locally owned place to get lunch, dinner or a treat, and staff is always friendly!!
Omg. Love the ice cream as much as I love the food. You know when you crave a certain food and It won't leave your mind till you get it. That's Theo's. Friendly service and the new flavors are so exciting to try. Can't want for the next one.
Great soft serve ice cream stand. I ordered a hot fudge sundae which was great. My guest ordered a twist cone which was very good. Next time I might try the chilli dogs!