Theo's Ice Cream Menu (Update 2025)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Welcome to Theo's Ice Cream, a hidden gem located at 3633 N Gale Ave in Peoria, IL. This delightful spot offers an impressive range of frozen treats, including ice cream, frozen yogurt, and sundaes. Indulge your sweet tooth with choices such as a simple baby cone starting at just $1.10 or indulge in a decadent Super Sundae for $3.90, topped with favorites like hot fudge or fresh fruit.

Despite some quirky parking and a cash-only policy, customers rave about Theo’s vibrant flavors and friendly staff. The establishment is not just about ice cream; many patrons also enjoy the delicious food offerings, making it a perfect stop for any meal. The atmosphere is lively, especially during summer, ensuring a welcoming experience for families and ice cream aficionados alike. Don’t miss out on their unique creations, from scrumptious classics to innovative new flavors!

Ice Cream Frozen Yogurt Sundaes Specialty Sundaes Icebergs Specialty Drinks Slushies Soft Drinks Food

Ice Cream

Waffle Cone
$2.75

Large Cone
$2.75

Medium Cone
$2.20

Small Cone
$1.95

Baby Cone
$1.10

Pint
$2.85

Quart
$5.70

Waffle Cone
$3.30

Large Cone
$3.00

Medium Cone
$2.85

Small Cone
$2.60

Baby Cone
$1.45

Pint
$4.65

Quart
$9.30

Frozen Yogurt

Sundaes

Super Sundae
$3.90

Large Sundae
$3.30

Regular Sundae
$2.80

Sundae Toppings

Chocolate Syrup, Hot Fudge, Caramel, Strawberry, Blueberry, Peach, Pineapple, Apple, Triple berry, Black Raspberry, Marshmallow, Cherry, Butterscotch, Peanut Butter, Creme De Menthe

Banana Foster
$3.90

Banana Split
$5.15

Black Forest
$3.85

Hot Fudge Brownie With Nuts
$4.15

Peanut Parfait
$3.85

Strawberry Shortcake
$3.85

Tin Roof
$3.85

Taffy Apple
$3.85

Turtle Delight
$3.85

Specialty Sundaes

Icebergs

Xtra Large Iceberg
$7.80

Large Iceberg
$4.30

Regular Iceberg
$3.90

Kids Iceberg
$3.50

Xtra Large Double Up Iceberg
$9.90

Large Double Up Iceberg
$5.35

Regular Double Up Iceberg
$4.95

Iceberg Toppings

Strawberry Shortcake, Nutty Buddy, Cookie Dough, German Chocolate, Nestle Krunch, Moosetracks, Chocolate Covered Banana, Heath, MM, Rocky Road, Mint Chip, Peanut Butter Cup, Butter Finger, Theos Krunch, Cotton Candy, Oreo, 100 Grand, Peach Cobbler, Turtle, Chocolate Covered Cherry, Taffy Apple, Coconut Cream Pie, Pumpkin Pie, Apple Cobbler, Mudpie, Hawaiian, Mocha, Rice Krispie Treat, Nerds, Theos Whopper, Banana Cream Pie, Snickers, Smore, Andes Mint, Chunky Monkey, Tropical, Twix, Fudge Nut Brownie, Trippleberry Pie, Caramel Delight, Puppy Chow, Triple Peanut Butter, Birthday Cake, Scotcharoo, Kit Kat, RockNScott, Cheesecake.

Large Size Shake, Float, Freeze, Glacier
$3.80

Regular Size Shake, Float, Freeze, Glacier
$3.10

Large Malts
$3.95

Regular Malts
$3.25

Cappucino Chiller
$3.60

Lemon Shake Up
$3.30

Specialty Drinks

Slushies

Xtra Large Slushie
$4.55

Large Slushie
$2.60

Regular Slushie
$2.35

Small Slushie
$2.15

Slushie Flavors

Blue Raspberry, Watermelon, Cherry, Green Apple, Bubble Gum, Orange, Lime, Grape, Mango, Fruit Punch, Strawberry, Pink Lemonade.

Xtra Large
$2.15

Large
$2.05

Regular
$1.75

Flavors

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Dr. Pepper, Unsweet Tea, Mountain Dew, Root Beer

Soft Drinks

Food

Frito Pie
$4.40

Brat
$3.90

Burger
$4.10

Cheese Burger
$4.25

Chili Cheese Burger
$4.25

Chicken Breast Sandwich
$4.00

Chicken Salad Sandwich
$4.00

Bacon Chicken Ranch Sandwich
$4.95

BBQ Pork Sandwich
$4.50

Pork Chop Sandwich
$4.50

Polish Sausage
$3.95

Spicy Polish Sausage
$3.95

Ribeye Sandwich
$6.75

The Keira
$7.75

Hot Dog
$2.20

Chili Dog
$2.35

Chili Cheese Dog
$2.50

Tamale
$2.45

Chili Tamale
$2.90

Chili Cheese Tamale
$3.15

Taco Salad
$5.25

Nachos
$3.65

Nacho Toppings

Jalapenos, Tomatoes, Sour Cream
$0.70

Nacho Supreme
$4.75

BBQ Pork Nachos
$7.25

Soft Pretzel
$2.25

Soft Pretzel With Cheese Dip
$2.85

Popcorn
$1.85

Chips
$1.00